Appendix A: Reflective practice tools
Reflective practice tools
Inclusive governance requires ongoing reflection rather than one-off interventions. Governance cultures, behaviours and participation patterns develop over time and are often shaped by assumptions, habits and informal dynamics that may not always be immediately visible to boards themselves.
Regular reflective practice can help boards better understand how governance operates in practice, identify barriers to participation and consider whether governance environments support meaningful contribution from a broad range of members and perspectives.
These questions are intended to support reflection, discussion and continuous improvement rather than compliance or performance assessment.
Questions for boards: Boards may wish to reflect on:
Governance culture and participation
- Who speaks most frequently during meetings?
- Whose contributions appear to carry the greatest influence?
- Are all directors equally encouraged to participate?
- How are interruptions, disagreement and challenge managed?
- Do newer directors feel able to contribute openly and confidently?
- What informal behaviours or norms shape participation within meetings?
Boards should consider not only who is present within governance spaces, but how participation and influence are distributed in practice.
Assumptions, legitimacy and experience
- What assumptions do we make about “experience,” professionalism or governance readiness?
- How do we define leadership, competence or credibility?
- Are some forms of experience valued more highly than others?
- How might age, background, confidence or communication style shape perceptions of legitimacy?
- Are there individuals or groups who may feel pressure to overperform in order to be heard or taken seriously?
These questions can help boards examine how wider social assumptions and governance norms may influence participation and decision-making.
Influence, decision-making and power
- How are decisions shaped before, during and after meetings?
- Are some individuals more influential due to length of service, confidence or existing relationships?
- How does the board respond to challenge or disagreement?
- Are quieter voices actively encouraged into discussion?
- Does participation lead to meaningful influence, or primarily attendance and observation?
Boards should recognise that influence may operate informally as well as formally within governance environments.
Renewal, representation and future governance
- What perspectives or lived experiences may currently be missing from governance discussions?
- Does the board reflect the diversity of its membership and communities?
- How are future directors identified, developed and supported?
- Are governance pathways visible and accessible to a broad range of members?
- How does the board balance continuity, institutional memory and renewal?
Reflective governance involves recognising both strengths and gaps within existing governance cultures and structures.
Using reflective practice
Boards may wish to use these questions:
- During board reviews or evaluations
- As part of governance effectiveness discussions
- Within board development sessions
- During recruitment or succession planning
- Or as part of wider organisational reflection on participation and accountability
The purpose is not to produce perfect governance cultures, but to support ongoing learning, reflection and improvement over time.