Skip to main content
Inclusive, intergenerational and intersectional governance

2. Review

2.1 Why some people do not join, stay, or progress in governance

While governance structures may appear formally open and accessible to all members, participation in practice is shaped by a range of structural and cultural factors that influence who is able to join, remain, and progress within board roles. 

Barriers do not operate in isolation; rather, they are closely connected and often mutually reinforcing, particularly for individuals experiencing multiple forms of inequality.

Practical barriers such as time, remuneration, accessibility or governance knowledge do not exist separately from governance culture and behaviour. Assumptions about professionalism, competence, confidence or ‘fit’ can shape how structural barriers are experienced, who feels able to navigate governance environments, and whose participation is supported or valued. As a result, participation in governance is influenced not only by formal access, but also by the interaction between organisational systems, board culture and wider social inequalities. 

Understanding these barriers is essential to recognising that underrepresentation in governance is not simply a question of interest or capability, but also of access, opportunity, and organisational culture.

Recruitment and representation

The way governance opportunities are advertised, promoted and described can influence who feels encouraged to apply. Recruitment processes may unintentionally reinforce exclusion where governance experience is presented as essential, pathways into governance are unclear, or language assumes familiarity with board environments. 

In such contexts, individuals who do not already identify with governance environments may be less likely to see themselves as suitable candidates, even where they have relevant lived experience, insight or transferable skills.

Boards should consider whether vacancies are advertised only through established member and professional networks, or also through wider and more accessible channels, such as member communications, community networks, youth organisations, relevant sector networks and accessible online platforms. 

Representation is therefore shaped not only by who applies, but by how accessible and visible the route into governance appears.

Elections and informal bias

In democratically elected governance structures, such as co-operatives, formal equality of opportunity can still be shaped by informal dynamics. Elections may be influenced by familiarity, visibility and recognition, meaning that individuals who are already known within the organisation or wider network may have a structural advantage. This can create a tendency towards ‘recognition voting’, where existing relationships or reputational familiarity influence outcomes. 

As a result:

  • Elections may function as popularity contests as well as democratic processes, creating a sense among some members that there is little point in standing when outcomes appear to favour familiar or already-established candidates
  • Candidates with existing social capital may be advantaged, and those from underrepresented groups may face additional barriers to being selected or elected
  • Where turnout is low, those who are repeatedly elected may come to see their continued election as evidence of a strong democratic mandate or legitimacy, even where only a relatively small proportion of the membership has voted

Without clear support, transparent criteria, and active encouragement, electoral processes may therefore reproduce existing governance demographics rather than broaden participation.

Accessibility, onboarding, retention

Practical barriers can significantly affect who is able to participate in governance. These may include meeting times, caring responsibilities, remuneration, accessibility needs, digital access, governance language and the availability of clear information.

Effective onboarding is equally important. New directors are more likely to participate confidently where they receive a structured induction, opportunities to build relationships, clear role expectations and accessible governance materials. Co-operatives UK’s Induction Checklist lays the foundation for effective onboarding. 

Crucially, barriers do not end once someone joins a board. Participation, confidence and progression are often shaped by access to informal networks, opportunities to develop governance knowledge and the extent to which individuals feel welcomed, valued and able to contribute.

Boards that focus only on recruitment may improve representation without improving inclusion. Effective governance requires attention to the full participation journey, from initial engagement through to meaningful contribution, retention and progression into leadership roles. 

Intersectional barriers

Barriers to participation are not experienced equally. Factors such as age, disability, race, gender, class, caring responsibilities, education and income can interact to create different experiences of governance access and participation. Boards should therefore avoid treating underrepresentation as uniform and instead recognise how overlapping factors affect governance access, confidence, and influence. 

Boards should recognise that legitimacy is shaped socially as well as formally. Holding a board position does not automatically guarantee that all directors experience equal confidence, influence or participation within governance discussions. For example, neurodivergent people may find some of the more ‘natural’ or informal routes into relationships, networks and shared understanding harder to access, particularly where expectations are implicit rather than clearly communicated. Please see Co-operatives UK’s Neurodiversity in the Boardroom guidance for more information.