Skip to main content
Funded by Access – the Foundation for Social Investment

Otley Common: Community shares bringing a vital local space to life

Image
People at an event at Otley Common

Thanks to an ambitious community share offer and support from the Community Shares Booster Fund, a former West Yorkshire Methodist church has been transformed into a thriving arts and community hub.

When the civic centre in Otley closed in 2010, it left the West Yorkshire town without a large venue for community events, arts and entertainment. The building remained mothballed for years before being sold and converted into flats.

“We lost our big community space,” said Andrew Howarth, Development Manager at Otley Common. “Despite Otley having some great pubs and smaller venues, this loss meant we couldn’t attract larger events.”

So when a local Methodist church came up for sale in 2023, local people, including Andrew, hatched a plan – to buy the building and turn it into a community‑owned venue. The group soon established Friends of the Wesley Otley Limited as a community benefit society.

Quote mark
We knew we needed to raise a lot of money for the purchase and renovation costs, so the key factor in becoming a community benefit society was how it would enable us to access share capital.
– Andrew Howarth, Development Manager, Otley Common

The group developed a business plan and launched a community share offer in June 2024. Support from the Community Shares Booster Fund, delivered by Co‑operatives UK, helped them prepare the offer.

A development grant paid for specialist consultancy, helping the group develop its offer document and secure the Community Shares Standard Mark – the guarantee of a high‑quality share offer.

“Ours was a particularly difficult share offer to write. It was a complicated ask with lots of grey areas. So the Booster Fund grant was a great help. It gave us access to an expert with the kind of knowledge that helped us get things right.”

The Fund also invested £50,000 in the share offer, providing a significant boost as the group worked towards its fundraising target.

Quote mark
Being able to show that the Booster Fund was investing gave us more legitimacy with other organisations, including Otley Town Council. They could see that an organisation able to carry out due diligence had confidence in us.
– Andrew Howarth, Development Manager, Otley Common
Discover our Contact Package...
It gives our members expert support with co‑operative governance, finance, HR and more.

An unexpected increase in the Booster Fund’s investment came at a crucial moment too.

“We were getting towards September and needed to hit our minimum target of £720,000. We kept asking the Methodists to give us another three months before completing the purchase of the church,” Andrew recalled.

“Then, all of a sudden, we got a call from the Community Shares Unit saying there was another £20,000 available. It was a massive morale boost and got us closer to the target.”

The share offer attracted around £450,000, with almost 80% of investors coming from Otley and the wider Leeds area. Alongside £300,000 from the Community Ownership Fund, a £100,000 interest‑free loan and other contributions, Friends of the Wesley Otley secured the funding they needed.

They bought the building in October 2025 for £490,000, named it Otley Common and have since been transforming it into a multi‑purpose community venue.

Renovations have included structural repairs and the refurbishment of former Sunday school rooms into studios for local businesses, artists and charities. Existing community groups have continued using the building throughout the work, with new activities gradually being introduced.

Image
People playing table tennis

Demand for events and activities continues to grow – and Otley Common now employs five people. It hosts a programme of classes, performances and community events, including comedy, music, calligraphy and history talks. A new table tennis club has proved particularly popular.

“It’s engaged so many young and old people, from six-year-olds to 86-year-olds,” Andrew said. “It’s been a real cross‑generational success.”

There’s still more to do, with further renovations to complete and plans to develop a food offer and make even more of the building’s spaces. And as Otley Common grows and works towards its longer‑term financial targets, the ambition is for it to become a sustainable community asset for generations to come – a place where people of all ages can meet, take part, celebrate, connect and create.

“We’re getting there. People are coming all the time and we’re getting emails every day asking about parties, classes and groups. It’s been brilliant.”

Find out more 

Otley Common – Website | Facebook | Instagram 

Think community shares might work for your community business?
Find out what support is available.
Related content